Robert Fagan: The Irish Neoclassical Painter and Archaeologist of Rome

Among our Neoclassical objects of admiration is the work of Robert Fagan (1761–1816), the Irish bohemian painter in Italy whose artistic achievements and archaeological discoveries in Rome distinguish him in the history of 18th- and early 19th-century art. Often described in his own time as “a great digger” and sometimes as an “amateur,” Fagan spent most of his career in Rome and Sicily, producing accomplished Neoclassical portraits while conducting numerous excavations in Roman tombs, villas, and temples. His unusual career bridged painting, archaeology, diplomacy, and the cultural networks of the Grand Tour.

Born in London to a family originally from Cork, Ireland, Robert Fagan grew up in a cosmopolitan environment. His father, Michael, ran a bakery in Covent Garden, but the young Fagan’s ambitions reached far beyond commerce. After studying at the Royal Academy, he traveled to Rome in 1781 with the painter Charles Grignion. This marked the start of a life in which he became both an Irish Neoclassical painter and a dealer in antiquities, with clients among the British and Irish aristocracy.

Robert Fagan, The Artist and his Wife, c. 1804, oil on canvas, Hunt Museum, Limerick

Once in Rome, Fagan quickly recognized the opportunities of the Grand Tour. A persuasive and ambitious figure, he lodged near the Spanish Steps alongside fellow painters, while offering Grand Tour travelers authentic and sometimes less-than-authentic antiquities. Wealthy British and Irish visitors sought paintings and souvenirs of their time in Italy, and Fagan positioned himself perfectly to serve this market. Among his patrons were Prince Augustus Frederick, later Duke of Sussex, Sir Andrew Corbet Corbet, and Frederick Hervey, the Earl-Bishop of Derry. These relationships granted him access to excavation permits and the highest levels of Roman society.

His archaeological pursuits in Rome were extensive. In 1793 he obtained a coveted license from the papal treasury, the Reverenda Camera, giving him the right to excavate across Rome and the Papal States. His discoveries were significant: the tomb of Claudia Semne on the Via Appia, the Temple of Mithras near Ostia, and statues such as the Diana now in the Louvre, the Venus of Campo Iemini now in the British Museum, and further sculptures now in Los Angeles and the Vatican. These finds reveal both his skill as an excavator and his talent as a negotiator, securing papal permission to export antiquities at a time when such licenses were tightly controlled.

As Raleigh Trevelyan noted in his 1972 Apollo article “Robert Fagan: An Irish Bohemian in Italy,” Fagan embodied the contradictions of his age.

His familiarity with classical art profoundly influenced his Neoclassical painting style. Fagan’s portraits combined realism with allegorical and classical motifs, offering sitters not just likenesses but also a connection to ancient ideals. Among his most celebrated works is the 1803 self-portrait with his second wife, Maria Ludovica Flajani, today in the Hunt Museum in Limerick. This painting is one of our favorites, showing Fagan with a commanding, aloof expression, while his bride gazes at him dressed ‘à la grecque’. As one writer put it: “In this double portrait, Fagan’s gaze is as much about affection as artistry, blending personal intimacy with the painterly elegance of his age.” The canvas captures both Neoclassical ideals and private emotion, making it central to Fagan’s reputation as an Irish bohemian portrait artist in Rome.

Other works confirm his range. His portraits of Lady Emma Hamilton captured her famous theatrical “attitudes,” reflecting the influence of performance on his approach to composition and costume. His family portraits of Anna Maria Rosa Ferri and their daughter Elestina, along with allegorical works such as Portrait of a Lady as Hibernia (a patriotic response to the Act of Union of 1801), reveal his ability to combine intimacy, symbolism, and Neoclassical grandeur.

Robert Fagan’s life was restless. He moved between Rome, Naples, and Sicily, balancing painting, excavation, and commerce while navigating the political instability of Napoleonic Europe. In 1807 he relocated to Sicily, where he briefly served as British consul-general. He often signed his works proudly as “His Britannic Majesty’s Consul General for Sicily,” even as financial troubles and personal tragedies weighed on him. The death of his first wife in 1801 left a lasting scar, though he continued to produce portraits for British patrons.

Tragically, in 1816, plagued by debt and melancholia, Fagan ended his life in Rome. His widow later sold his collection to the Vatican. His unfinished travel narrative, The Island of Sicily Respecting its Antiquities, remains in the British Library. His descendants, including his grandson Louis, continued to contribute to European art institutions, but Robert Fagan himself slipped into obscurity.

For modern readers, however, his story deserves renewed attention. He represents the complexities of an age when artists were also dealers, diplomats, and cultural mediators. His works are dispersed in major collections—the Hunt Museum in Limerick, the British Museum, the Louvre, the Vatican Museums, and private holdings—yet together they form a portrait of an ambitious Irish artist navigating Rome’s cosmopolitan networks.

As Raleigh Trevelyan noted in his 1972 Apollo article “Robert Fagan: An Irish Bohemian in Italy,” Fagan embodied the contradictions of his age. Trevelyan observed that he was at once opportunistic and creative, ambitious yet vulnerable, admired and mistrusted. Those insights remain striking today. They help us understand why Fagan was both a bohemian Irish painter in Italy and a figure whose life was inseparable from the turbulence and brilliance of the late eighteenth century.

Robert Fagan’s legacy is that of a painter-archaeologist who merged classical scholarship with intimate portraiture. His self-portrait with Maria Ludovica Flajani remains an icon of Neoclassical elegance tinged with personal depth, while his excavations and diplomatic roles demonstrate the blurred boundaries between art, commerce, and politics. His life shows us that art history is not only about the most famous names, but also about passionate individuals whose creativity and daring shaped the cultural landscape of Europe. 

Outlines from the Figures and Compositions upon the Greek, Roman, and Etruscan Vases of the Late Sir William Hamilton

Limited edition classical art book featuring Thomas Kirk's masterful archaeological engravings from 1804. Hand-bound in half leather with marbled boards.

$750.00

View Book